36.1 C

OpenAI claims the Times cheated to get ChatGPT to regurgitate articles



OpenAI has claimed in a motion filed Monday that The New York Times used “deceptive prompts” to get ChatGPT to regurgitate its content. For that and other reasons, the company is asking the US District Court in southern New York to dismiss several of the claims in the outlet’s copyright infringement lawsuit.

OpenAI asserts that the Times exploited a bug that it’s currently working to fix and that the outlet fed articles directly to the chatbot to get it to spit out verbatim passages. “Normal people do not use OpenAI’s products this way,” the company says, citing an April 2023 Times article titled “35 Ways Real People Are Using A.I. Right Now.” This is all very similar to the arguments OpenAI made in its public response in January.

Times lead counsel Ian Crosby told The Verge in an email that calling the outlet’s efforts a hack is a mischaracterization and that the outlet was “simply using OpenAI’s products to look for evidence that they stole and reproduced The Times’s copyrighted works.” He added that OpenAI doesn’t deny “it copied Times works without permission within the statute of limitations.”

The Times sued OpenAI and Microsoft in December, claiming the companies trained their AI models on its content and that their chatbots could reproduce the stories verbatim. The publication alleged that this deprives it of revenue and compromises its relationship with its readers.

OpenAI is looking to partially dismiss the Times’ count of direct copyright infringement “to the extent it is based on acts of reproduction that occurred more than three years before this action.” It also asks the court to dismiss other allegations: that OpenAI contributed to the infringement; that it had failed to remove infringing information; and that it created unfair competition by misappropriation. The Times lawsuit also alleges counts of trademark dilution, common law unfair competition by misappropriation, and a vicarious copyright infringement claim.

OpenAI similarly whittled down complaints in a lawsuit from Sarah Silverman and other authors to a single direct copyright infringement claim. As successful as its bid was and this one could be, the two aren’t the only lawsuits against AI companies. Startups like OpenAI, Anthropic, and Stability AI are looking into a steadily widening maw of legal action right now, some of it from experienced and litigious organizations with sometimes decades of copyright battles under their belts. As The Verge’s Nilay Patel and Sarah Jeong recently discussed on the Decoder podcast, the cases have the potential to upend or even obliterate the nascent industry.

Source link

Subscribe to our magazine

━ more like this

Apple backtracks and approves the first PC emulator for iOS

UTM SE is a PC emulator that allows you to run classic software and old-school games.* Supports both VGA mode for graphics and...

Biden says ‘everybody must condemn’ attack on Trump as campaign halts messaging to supporters and pulls TV ads

President Joe Biden said Saturday that “everybody must condemn” the suspected assassination attempt on former President Donald Trump, adding that he hoped to speak with his 2024 presidential...

Donald Trump taken off stage during rally after apparent gunshots; Secret Service says he is safe

Donald Trump’s campaign said in a statement that he was “fine” after being whisked off the stage at a rally in Butler, Pennsylvania...

Call your shot: Investors are buying individual stocks at a record pace as market-beating bets dwindle to lowest ever

More investors are calling their shots and picking out individual stocks to buy as market gains become concentrated in an increasingly narrow range...

A trip to Shanghai’s AI mega-conference showed me that China’s developers are still playing catch-up to Silicon Valley

Last week, Shanghai hosted China’s largest AI event: The World Artificial Intelligence Conference (WAIC), with 500 exhibitors, 1,500 exhibits, over 300,000 attendees, and...